Hot Take: Stan Culture Is Both the Lifeline and the Poison of Modern Music

Paul Bergen / Redferns / Getty

The same fans who stream songs into existence can also tear an artist down in 280 characters.

Stan culture is the reason many artists still have careers in 2025, but it’s also why some can’t sleep at night. Passion is powerful, and online communities have turned that passion into entire ecosystems. But when love turns into possession, the same force that fuels a career can start to quietly destroy it.

No label marketing plan can compete with an organized fandom. Stans trend hashtags, stream albums overnight, and dissect every lyric as if it’s sacred text. They’re the reason eras last longer than album cycles and why nostalgia is constantly reborn on TikTok.

It’s easy to forget how much good stan culture has done. Fans have raised money for charities in their favorite artist’s name, revived forgotten songs, and even helped new artists break into the mainstream. This is the beauty of fandom; connection, community, and a shared sense of purpose that keeps the music world alive.

---

When Support Crosses the Line

But somewhere along the way, connection turned into control.

Parasocial culture, also known as the illusion of a personal relationship between fan and artist, has blurred the line between admiration and obsession. Every post is decoded like a secret message. Every lyric becomes a breadcrumb. And when artists dare to live lives outside the fan narrative, the backlash hits hard.

The expectation for constant accessibility drains artists. They’re expected to be endlessly relatable, emotionally available, and online 24/7. Authenticity becomes performance, and privacy becomes rebellion.

The darkest part? How that same devotion fuels online bullying. Entire fanbases go to war online, harassing journalists, critics, and even other fans who don’t share the same opinions. It becomes a sport. Who can defend their fave the loudest, even if it means tearing someone else apart.

We’ve seen this too many times. Artists lose control of their own narratives because fans are fighting battles they never asked for. The irony? The same love meant to protect ends up isolating them further.

---

Passion vs. Possession

It’s not hard to imagine why so many artists log off.

The constant noise, praise, critique, and speculation can feel like standing under a spotlight that never dims. The fear of disappointing fans, of being “canceled” by the very people who helped build their career, keeps many in survival mode.

Some are choosing boundaries over burnout, limiting online interaction, hiding comment sections, or creating music purely for themselves again. That might be the healthiest rebellion of all.

Stan culture isn’t all bad. It’s proof that music still matters enough to make people feel something. But passion has to come with perspective. You can stream, show up, and hype your favorite artists without crossing into toxicity.

At the end of the day, music is supposed to unite us, not turn connection into competition.

Because passion keeps the music alive, but respect keeps it human.