EP REVIEW: Midnight Til Morning — Afterglow

Midnight Til Morning might’ve started on Netflix’s Building the Band, but they’ve quickly outgrown the “reality show project” label. The four-piece — Conor Smith, Mason Watts, Shane Appell, and Zach Newbould — is a group that feels built from connection, chemistry, and real musicianship. They’re not your average boy band, they play their own instruments, write their own songs, and bring an energy that feels more like friends in a jam session than a manufactured act. Afterglow captures that perfectly; a debut that feels genuine, emotionally aware, and ridiculously catchy.

---

THE GLOW OF SOMETHING REAL

“Bye” opens the EP with that bittersweet punch of heartbreak. It’s pop perfection but still grounded, like you can feel the weight of the goodbye they’re trying not to say. It’s one of those songs that sneaks up on you, bright enough to dance to, but aching underneath. Then “Heart on Fire” shifts the mood entirely. It’s sun-soaked and easy, the kind of track that feels like summer in full color. You can picture the moment, picnic blankets, city parks, someone smiling across from you, all wrapped up in that acoustic pop warmth.

And just when you’re floating, “Ghost of Us” hits. The guitars get heavier, the vocals go raw, and suddenly you’re in the middle of something bigger. It’s the track that shows off what they can really do - that balance between grit and harmony, edge and emotion. It’s proof that Midnight Til Morning aren’t chasing radio polish; they’re chasing feeling.

---

POP WITH A PULSE

Afterglow doesn’t try to be everything — it just knows what it is. Emotional, earnest, and alive. There’s a sincerity in how this band approaches their sound, a reminder that pop doesn’t have to mean artificial. You can hear the real instruments, the breath in the harmonies, the weight of the words. It’s the kind of debut that doesn’t need flash. It just wins you over by simply being human.

Midnight Til Morning are carving out their own lane in the pop space. One where heart, honesty, and hooks can coexist. If Afterglow is any indication, this band is only getting started… and we’re already hitting replay.

Catch Midnight Til Morning on tour across North America, Europe and Australia